Go to content

2026_19_3_3 - XLinguae

Skip menu
Skip menu

2026_19_3_3

Open access Issues > Issue n_3_2026 > Issue n_3_2026
Philosophy, Religion, and State: The Nguyễn Dynasty and Its Implications for Contemporary Vietnamese Religious Policy

Bùi Thị Thủy

DOI: 10.18355/XL.2026.19.03.03

Abstract
The Nguyễn Dynasty (1802–1945) presents a puzzle. The same court that grounded its legitimacy in a Confucian moral-cosmological order shaped by tam giáo đồng nguyên (the philosophical doctrine about the convergence of the three teachings) drove the most thoroughgoing Confucianization of Vietnamese institutions any dynasty had attempted and produced the country’s most severe anti-Catholic edicts. Religious pluralism within, religious exclusion at the boundary. This article reads the puzzle philosophically rather than as policy history or sociology of religion. It argues that the Nguyễn court’s engagement with religion instantiates three differentiated philosophical postures of the state toward religious otherness — accommodation, control, and exclusion — keyed not to a chronological sequence across reigns but to the philosophical-anthropological compatibility of each tradition with the state’s account of person, community, and political authority. The three-model typology, recast as a typology of philosophical postures, is engaged with the Western philosophy of religion (Charles Taylor, Talal Asad, Jürgen Habermas, William Cavanaugh), with Confucian political-religious anthropology (Tu Weiming), and with Vietnamese philosophical voices (Trần Đình Hượu, Phan Ngọc, Lương Kim Định) that the Anglophone literature has rarely engaged as substantive interlocutors. The contemporary stakes follow. Vietnam’s post-2003 reform consensus, the 2016 Belief and Religion Law, and the 13th Party Congress’s “religion as resource” formulation operationalize a philosophical disposition continuous with the deeper Vietnamese inheritance of tam giáo đồng nguyên. The lesson is philosophical, not nostalgic: a state’s relation to religion is most stable when its philosophical commitments toward person, community, and transcendence are made explicit and operationalized in transparent legal-procedural form. The Vietnamese case thereby contributes a worked non-Western answer to a universal philosophical question.

Key words: Nguyễn Dynasty, philosophy of religion, state-religion relations, tam giáo đồng nguyên, Charles Taylor, Tu Weiming, Vietnamese Catholicism

Pages: 32-48

Full Text
Back to content